In recent years, the Western diet, characterized by high consumption of sugars through beverages and heavily processed foods, has been implicated in the rising prevalence of obesity and diabetes. A growing body of evidence suggests that reducing refined carbohydrates, including free and added sugars, can improve glycemic control in individuals with diabetes. However, the impact of such dietary changes on those without diabetes has been less clear. A recent study sought to bridge this knowledge gap by examining the effects of reducing free sugar intake on 24-hour glucose profiles and glycemic variability in non-diabetic individuals.

Study Design and Methodology

The study was a randomized controlled trial involving 21 participants, both normal weight and overweight/obese (BMI 18-40 kg/m²), without diabetes. The participants were divided into two groups: one following a reduced-sugar (RS) diet and the other continuing their habitual diet as a control. The trial spanned six weeks, beginning with a two-week baseline phase where all participants maintained their usual dietary habits. This was followed by a four-week intervention phase.

During the intervention phase, the RS group was instructed to eliminate added sugars and white flour products from their diet. The control group, meanwhile, continued with their usual dietary patterns. Researchers measured anthropometric parameters and HbA1c levels both before and after the intervention. Continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) was used to assess interstitial glucose levels, while participants documented their food intake for 14 consecutive days during both the baseline and intervention phases.

Findings and Analysis

The study’s findings provided valuable insights into the effects of sugar reduction on various health metrics:

1. Dietary Changes: Participants in the RS group significantly reduced their daily intake of sugar by an average of 22.4 grams (equivalent to a reduction of 3.28% of their total energy intake), total carbohydrates by 6.22%, and total energy intake by 216 calories. Conversely, their protein intake increased by 2.51%. These dietary changes were notably different from the control group, which did not alter their dietary habits.
2. Anthropometric Outcomes: The RS group experienced modest reductions in body weight (averaging a loss of 1.58 kg), BMI, total fat, and visceral fat content. They also saw an increase in muscle mass compared to their baseline measurements. However, these changes were not significantly different from those observed in the control group.
3. Glycemic Control: Despite the dietary changes and associated weight loss, the RS diet did not significantly affect 24-hour mean glucose levels or intra- and inter-day indices of glucose variability. Measures such as the standard deviation (SD) around the sensor glucose level, coefficient of variation (CV), mean amplitude of glucose excursions (MAGE), continuous overlapping net glycemic action (CONGA), and mean absolute glucose (MAG) remained unchanged in both within- and between-group comparisons. Additionally, there were no significant changes in HbA1c levels or diurnal glucose patterns.

Implications and Conclusions

The study concluded that while reducing free sugar intake leads to beneficial changes in body weight and body fat, these improvements are likely linked to a reduction in total energy intake rather than direct effects on glycemic control. For individuals without diabetes, decreasing sugar consumption did not significantly impact daily mean glucose levels or glycemic variability.

These findings have important implications for dietary recommendations and public health strategies. Although reducing sugar intake is beneficial for weight management and overall health, it may not be sufficient to influence glycemic control in non-diabetic individuals. This suggests that other dietary and lifestyle interventions might be necessary to achieve optimal glucose regulation in this population.

Future Research Directions

The study highlights the need for further research to explore the long-term effects of sugar reduction on metabolic health, particularly in diverse populations and different age groups. Additionally, investigating the combined impact of sugar reduction with other dietary modifications, such as increased fiber intake or reduced fat consumption, could provide a more comprehensive understanding of how to improve glycemic control in non-diabetics.

Overall, this study underscores the complexity of dietary influences on health and the importance of tailored dietary recommendations. While reducing sugar intake is a valuable component of a healthy diet, it should be considered as part of a broader strategy that includes balanced nutrition and other lifestyle changes to promote optimal health and prevent metabolic disorders.

Other Topics: Medicine and Health Science, Natural Science, Agricultural Science, Engineering & Technology, Social Sciences & Humanities